Lost in Translation Series:  Reel Four

Direct & Indirect Communication

Do you equate good communication with being clear and direct?

Or with showing respect and maintaining harmony?

It depends on who you ask.

Scene One:

The Living Room (Japan)

A Japanese father sits in the living room.
He doesn’t look up.
He simply says, softly:

“Haizara.” (Ashtray)

An American guest would hear a request for one thing: the ashtray.

But his daughter hears everything implied — 

She brings the ashtray, his lighter, his cigarettes on a small tray. 
Then heads to the kitchen to prepare tea.


This scene reflects the quiet choreography of a Japanese proverb, first found in Confucius’s Analects:
Ichi o kiite, jū o shiru — hear one, understand ten.

He said one word.
She understood ten.

Scene Two:

The Car (Mexico)

Two colleagues are driving after a long day.
The window is open, and the evening air is getting cold.

The Mexican colleague looks out and says, softly:
“The weather’s really starting to get cold, isn’t it.”

The American nods, and says:  “Yes, it is.”

A moment passes.
She tries again.

“Aren’t you cold?”

He answers the question: “No, I’m fine.”

The window stays open.
The cold keeps drifting in. 


She delivered the cue.
He misread the scene.

The scene ends. The confusion doesn't.

The Series.

Communication shapes every cross-border relationship.

Equip your leaders and teams with customized coaching and training.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}